7 Differences Between Rugby and American Football
Rugby and American football are two of the most physically demanding and popular sports worldwide. Though they share common origins and a focus on physicality, the differences between the two are vast, influencing gameplay, strategy, and the athlete’s experience. From equipment and tackling techniques to the playing field and rules, understanding the key distinctions helps appreciate each sport’s unique identity. This article delves into the 7 major differences between rugby and American football.
Written by
- Redaction Team
- Professional Career, Professional Development
Table of Contents
1. Number of Players: Rugby vs American Football
One of the first noticeable differences between rugby and American football lies in the number of players on the field. A rugby union team fields 15 players, while a rugby league team uses 13. In contrast, an American football team fields 11 players at a time.
Each rugby player is generally required to both attack and defend throughout the match. However, in American football, specialization is key; players are divided into offense, defense, and special teams, often focusing on highly specific roles. This specialization is one of the most prominent differences between the two sports, leading to different styles of gameplay and athletic training.
2. Protective Gear: Rugby and American Football Players Wear Different Equipment
American football players wear helmets, shoulder pads, thigh guards, and other extensive protection to handle the intense tackles and collisions. The standard American player is heavily geared to prevent serious injuries during the fast-paced, high-impact game.
Rugby players don’t wear nearly as much protective gear. Typically, a rugby player might wear a mouthguard and sometimes soft headgear, but otherwise, protection is minimal. Rugby and American football differ significantly here: rugby emphasizes safe tackling techniques due to the lack of protective armor, whereas American football relies on protective equipment to absorb the force.
3. Tackle Rules and Safety: How Tackles Differ in Rugby and Football
The rules of rugby around tackling are much stricter than those in American football. In rugby, once a player is tackled, they must immediately release the ball and allow play to continue. This encourages a safer style of tackling where the tackler wraps the opponent and brings them to the ground without high-speed collisions.
In American football, tackling often involves hitting the ball carrier with maximum force to stop forward progress. The American football the attacking team retains possession after a tackle unless the ball is fumbled or intercepted. Therefore, the objective of the tackle is drastically different between rugby and football.
Some argue that rugby is safer than American football because of the emphasis on controlled tackles, despite the lack of heavy padding.
4. The Ball and How It's Moved: Rugby Ball vs Football Ball
Both rugby and American football use oval-shaped balls, but the rugby ball is slightly larger and less pointed than the American football. This difference affects how the ball can be handled, passed, and kicked.
In rugby, players mostly kick the ball forward or pass it laterally or backward to maintain possession. Forward passes are not allowed. In contrast, American football permits forward passes, and throwing the ball forward is a key element of advancing on the field.
Another major difference between rugby and American football is the method of advancing the ball: in rugby, the ball must constantly be moved with quick passes and strategic kicks, while in American football, a team can advance by running or throwing after lining up for a play.
5. The Playing Field: Rugby Pitch vs American Football Field
The dimensions of rugby fields and American football fields vary significantly. A rugby pitch typically measures about 100 meters (328 feet) in length and 70 meters (230 feet) in width, with in-goal areas extending 5.5 to 24 yards beyond the try line.
The American football field is 100 yards long and 53.3 yards wide, with two 10-yard end zones on either side. Therefore, the playing field in American football is narrower and shorter overall compared to a rugby field.
Field in rugby allows for a more expansive style of play, whereas in American football, the tighter space emphasizes quick, strategic plays and formation shifts.
6. Scoring Systems: American Football vs Rugby
A touchdown is the American football equivalent of a try in rugby. In American football, a touchdown is worth six points, followed by the opportunity for an extra point or a two-point conversion.
In rugby, a try is worth five points, and after scoring a try, the team has an opportunity to kick for two additional points, called a conversion.
Another difference between rugby and American football is how field goals are handled. In American football, a field goal during open play is worth three points. In rugby, a drop goal can be attempted at any time and is worth three points, contributing to the dynamic scoring possibilities in both sports.
7. Game Duration and Play Continuity: Rugby and Football Rules Compared
The rugby world cup games and standard rugby matches are played in two 40-minute halves, with continuous play that only stops for infringements or when the ball goes out of bounds.
An American football game consists of four 15-minute quarters, but the clock stops frequently for incomplete passes, changes in possession, and other events. As a result, while the actual playtime might be similar, the duration of an American football match often extends to over three hours.
In rugby, possession of the ball can change rapidly, and there are fewer stoppages, leading to a faster and more fluid game experience compared to the start-stop nature of professional football in the NFL or college football.
Conclusion: Rugby or American Football - Which One Fits You?
Choosing between rugby or American football depends largely on what aspects of the sport you value most. If you prefer a continuous, fast-paced game with less protective gear and a greater emphasis on endurance and multi-role play, rugby might be for you. If you enjoy strategic formations, specialized positions, and explosive plays, American football could be your game.
Understanding the differences between the two sports reveals why each has its passionate following. Whether it’s the rugby world cup drawing fans from around the globe or the NFL captivating millions on Sundays, the love for both sports stems from their unique challenges and thrills.
Ultimately, whether it’s football or rugby, both are spectacular versions of the athletic competition, and each offers a distinct way to enjoy the combination of strategy, strength, and teamwork.
More about Professional career
