Economy vs Premium Economy: Is the Upgrade Worth It?

When booking your next flight, choosing between economy and premium economy can make a big difference in your travel experience. For many travelers, the decision comes down to balancing comfort and cost. This article will break down the differences between economy class and premium economy to help you decide if the upgrade is worth the extra cost.

Economy vs Premium Economy: Is the Upgrade Worth It?
Written by
Table of Contents

Economy Class: The Standard Choice

Economy class, also known as coach, is the most budget-friendly option available on almost every airline. While it comes with the lowest economy fares, it’s often criticized for its limited space and comfort.

Key Features of Economy Class Seats

  • Typical coach seat dimensions:

    • Seat width: 17–18 inches
    • Seat pitch (legroom): 30–31 inches
    • Recline: Limited to 2–4 inches, depending on the airline.
  • Limited amenities:

    • Basic snack service or meal on long-haul flights.
    • Checked bags are often not included, depending on the airline’s economy fare policies.
  • Space and comfort:

    • Cramped seating can make longer flights uncomfortable.
    • No footrests or extra features that enhance relaxation.

For budget-conscious travelers or short-haul flights, economy class is often the default choice. However, even in economy, many airlines provide some degree of service and basic amenities.

Premium Economy: A Step Above

Premium economy is designed to bridge the gap between economy and business class fares, offering increased comfort without the substantially higher price of business and first-class. Airlines like American Airlines, United Airlines, Virgin Atlantic, and Air New Zealand offer distinct premium economy cabins for travelers seeking an enhanced experience.

What Sets Premium Economy Apart?

Premium Economy Seats

  • Wider seats: Typically 1–2 inches wider than economy class seats.
  • Extra legroom: Seat pitch ranges from 36–40 inches, providing more space to stretch.
  • Improved recline: Seats often recline more generously, sometimes up to 8 inches.
  • Added features: Many have footrests, cushy seats, and adjustable headrests for increased comfort.

Amenities for Premium Economy Passengers

  • Amenity kits: Some airlines provide premium economy customers with skincare products, socks, and eye masks.
  • Enhanced meals: Airlines provide upgraded dining options with better presentation and quality.
  • Additional luggage allowances: Premium economy fares often include more generous checked bags and carry-on allowances, such as 50 pounds for checked luggage and 22 pounds for carry-ons.
  • Priority check-in and boarding: Skip the long lines and board earlier.

Premium Economy Cabin Design

The premium economy cabin is typically located between economy class and business class. The design used in these cabins emphasizes space and comfort, making long-haul flights more enjoyable.

Is Premium Economy Worth It?

When to Consider Premium Economy

  1. Long-haul flights: The extra legroom and recline make a significant difference on flights over 6 hours.
  2. Business trips: Premium economy is worth considering when traveling for work but cannot justify the cost of business class fares.
  3. Special occasions: Whether it’s a honeymoon or a milestone trip, premium economy can enhance the experience.
  4. Frequent flyer upgrades: Redeemable miles may help you get premium economy for a fraction of the cost.

Cost Comparison

  • Economy fares are often the cheapest, with rates as low as $556 for Norwegian long-haul routes.
  • Premium economy fares can cost hundreds more, sometimes less, depending on the airline and route.
  • Sites like Kayak and NerdWallet can help compare prices and evaluate if the upgrade is worth the extra cost.

Expert Opinions

Airline experts say the value of premium economy depends on the airline, routing, and personal preferences. Using tools like SeatGuru can give insights into seat layouts and amenities for your next flight.

Comparing Economy vs Premium Economy

FeatureEconomy ClassPremium Economy
Seat width17–18 inches18–20 inches
Legroom30–31 inches36–40 inches
Recline2–4 inches7–8 inches
Checked luggageOften not includedTypically included
AmenitiesMinimalEnhanced
CostLowest faresSubstantially higher price

Popular Airlines Offering Premium Economy

  • American Airlines: Known for its premium economy cabins on international routes.
  • United Airlines: Offers Economy Plus with extra legroom and upgraded dining.
  • Virgin Atlantic: One of the best premium economy options, with stylish cabins and attentive service.
  • Air New Zealand: Recognized for its comfortable seats and exceptional amenities.
  • Cathay Pacific: Premium economy passengers enjoy enhanced dining and a more spacious cabin.

Alternatives to Premium Economy

If premium economy isn’t an option, here are some other ways to enhance your travel experience:

  1. Upgrade from economy: Some airlines provide last-minute opportunities to upgrade for a lower cost.
  2. Frequent flyer benefits: Loyalty programs may offer discounts or upgrades.
  3. Flexible dates: Use tools like Kayak Shows to find routes with better premium economy fares.

Conclusion

For many travelers, premium economy is worth the extra cost, particularly on long-haul flights or business trips. The added space, recline, and amenities can transform a tiring journey into a more enjoyable experience. Whether you’re flying for business or leisure, premium economy provides a sweet spot between economy and business class. Next time you book a flight, consider your priorities—comfort, budget, and travel experience—to decide if premium economy is the right choice for you.

Take action today by exploring premium economy options on your preferred airlines.

More about Business Planning