Plantain vs Banana: Understanding the Key Differences

Bananas and plantains are often found in the same produce section and, at first glance, can appear quite similar. However, there are several important differences between the two fruits that influence their taste, texture, and culinary uses. While both belong to the same family, their unique characteristics make them suited for different dishes, from sweet treats to savory meals. This article dives deep into the differences between plantains and bananas, their nutritional value, ripeness, and how they’re best enjoyed.

Plantain vs Banana: Understanding the Key Differences
Written by
Table of Contents

What are Bananas?

banana

Bananas, specifically the Cavendish banana, are one of the most popular fruits worldwide. Known for their sweet flavor and convenient portability, bananas are typically eaten raw when ripe.

Key Characteristics of Bananas:

  • Sweet Taste: Ripe bananas are known for their naturally sweet flavor.
  • Texture: Bananas have a soft, creamy texture when ripe.
  • Ripeness: As bananas ripen, they become sweeter and softer, often developing black spots.
  • Common Uses: Bananas are often eaten raw, added to desserts, used in smoothies, or baked into various treats like banana bread.

What are Plantains?

Whole yellow plantains

Plantains are a type of banana but with distinct differences in flavor, texture, and culinary use. They are larger, have a thicker skin, and are typically starchier than bananas, which makes them suitable for cooking.

Key Characteristics of Plantains:

  • Starchy Texture: Unlike bananas, plantains are much starchier and less sweet when unripe.
  • Ripeness: Plantains can be eaten at various stages of ripeness—from green (unripe) to yellow and black (fully ripe).
  • Savory or Sweet: While ripe plantains can be sweet, unripe ones are more savory and often used in cooking.
  • Common Uses: Plantains are commonly used in savory dishes, such as tostones (fried green plantains) and mofongo (mashed plantains). They can also be baked, fried, or boiled.

Key Differences Between Bananas and Plantains

While bananas and plantains share some similarities, they have distinct characteristics that make them suitable for different culinary uses.

Difference in Taste and Texture:

  • Bananas: Ripe bananas are sweet and soft, making them perfect for eating raw, as a snack, or in desserts.
  • Plantains: Unripe plantains are starchy and not sweet, making them ideal for savory dishes. As they ripen, they become sweeter and softer but remain denser than bananas.

Ripening Process:

  • Bananas: As bananas ripen, they become sweeter and softer. Ripe bananas are sweet and can be eaten raw or used in baked goods.
  • Plantains: Plantains require cooking, especially when they are green or yellow. When fully ripe (black spots), they become softer and sweeter but are still typically cooked before eating.

Size and Skin:

  • Bananas: Bananas are generally smaller and have a thin, easily peelable skin.
  • Plantains: Plantains are typically larger and have a thicker, tougher skin that’s harder to peel.

Nutritional Comparison: Bananas vs Plantains

Both bananas and plantains are highly nutritious and offer a range of health benefits, but they differ in their nutrient content.

Nutritional Breakdown:

  • Bananas: A typical banana contains about 23 grams of carbs and is a good source of potassium, vitamin C, and fiber. Bananas are relatively lower in calories, with around 89-122 calories per banana.
  • Plantains: Plantains contain roughly 32 grams of carbs per serving and are also rich in potassium, fiber, and vitamin C. They are denser and higher in calories, providing around 122-150 calories per serving, depending on ripeness.

Culinary Uses: Bananas vs Plantains

Both fruits are versatile, but they shine in different types of dishes based on their texture and flavor profile.

Bananas:

  • Raw: Bananas are typically eaten raw, often as a snack or in smoothies.
  • Dessert: They can be used in various sweet treats such as banana bread, banana pudding, and banana muffins.
  • Smoothies: Bananas make excellent additions to smoothies due to their creamy texture.

Plantains:

  • Savory Dishes: Plantains are most often used in savory dishes. Unripe (green) plantains are fried to make tostones or boiled to create plantain chips.
  • Mofongo: A popular dish in Puerto Rican and Dominican cuisine, mofongo is made by mashing plantains with garlic, pork, and other ingredients.
  • Fried Plantains (Maduros): Ripe plantains can be fried to create sweet maduros, often served as a side dish in Latin American meals.

Similarities Between Bananas and Plantains

Despite their differences, bananas and plantains share several similarities that make them cousins in the same family.

  • Banana Family: Both bananas and plantains belong to the same family, the banana family (Musaceae), and come from tropical regions.
  • High in Potassium: Both are excellent sources of potassium, which is essential for maintaining proper heart and muscle function.
  • Rich in Fiber: Both fruits provide a healthy dose of dietary fiber, aiding in digestion and gut health.
  • Versatility in Cooking: Both can be incorporated into a variety of dishes, from sweet to savory, depending on their ripeness and preparation.

How to Cook Plantains and Bananas

Each fruit requires a different cooking approach based on its ripeness and intended use.

Plantains:

  1. Green Plantains: Slice and fry to make tostones or cut into chunks and boil for use in savory dishes.
  2. Yellow Plantains: Fry for a sweet side dish or bake them for a softer texture.
  3. Ripe (Black) Plantains: Sweeten when fried or baked, and serve as a dessert or side dish.

Bananas:

  1. Raw: Eat as a snack, or use in smoothies, salads, or desserts.
  2. Baked Goods: Use mashed bananas to make banana bread, muffins, or pancakes.
  3. Fried: Slice and fry ripe bananas to make a simple dessert or snack.

Conclusion: Plantain vs Banana – Which One to Choose?

While bananas and plantains share a family lineage and some similarities, they each have distinct uses in the kitchen. Bananas are best eaten raw and are perfect for desserts or smoothies, while plantains are more versatile in savory dishes and are often fried, boiled, or mashed.

Whether you prefer the sweetness of ripe bananas or the starchiness of cooked plantains, both fruits are nutrient-rich and can be enjoyed in a variety of dishes. Understanding the difference between bananas and plantains will help you make the most of each fruit, based on your personal taste and the recipes you want to create.

More about Healing Foods